Actually...the cap where they are smiling together...is from AFTER 10.2 arrives. If you look at the 10.2 and 10 in the TARDIS moments...you will see that Rose turns toward 10 whenever he is there...and in this scene...she has slid in under his arm and they are delighting over Gwen looking like Gweneth. There is a shot of 11 looking over at them and smiling at their cooing. There is also a point where everyone hugs. If you pause your film there...you will see that Rose and 10 turn toward each other...we then see 10.2 hug Sarah Jane to his left (not Rose to his right) and Martha...hug Donna. This leaves 10 and Rose hugging but unseen. Then Rose goes to Martha...and 11 goes on his way. We see 10 get between Rose and Martha for another hug...just before we see Donna get between Jack and Sarah Jane.
Surely...if they mean to indicate that 11 is 10...then he and Rose should do a bit of flirting or hugging or something? I know she kisses him...but I also know she breaks out of the kiss and rushes toward her Doctor. And if 11 is the DOCTOR...kissing him doesn't prove very much...the pulling away and running does though.
And my cap comparison is about comfort...and love. And it is very fair...if 10.2 is the Doctor...why doesn't he react like the Doctor would...about being given a life with Rose. Why is it made uncertain? I can understand a little bit of uncertainty...I can't understand the distance between them...the complete lack of nudging and cooing and such. If nothing else...she should have leaned into him when he took her hand...but she shifts her hips AWAY from him. This isn't HER Doctor...it's A Doctor...Eleven...the one she says at the beginning of the episode she doesn't really want.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
(no subject)
Date: 2008-07-21 02:00 pm (UTC)Surely...if they mean to indicate that 11 is 10...then he and Rose should do a bit of flirting or hugging or something? I know she kisses him...but I also know she breaks out of the kiss and rushes toward her Doctor. And if 11 is the DOCTOR...kissing him doesn't prove very much...the pulling away and running does though.
And my cap comparison is about comfort...and love. And it is very fair...if 10.2 is the Doctor...why doesn't he react like the Doctor would...about being given a life with Rose. Why is it made uncertain? I can understand a little bit of uncertainty...I can't understand the distance between them...the complete lack of nudging and cooing and such. If nothing else...she should have leaned into him when he took her hand...but she shifts her hips AWAY from him. This isn't HER Doctor...it's A Doctor...Eleven...the one she says at the beginning of the episode she doesn't really want.
Rae